The Third Intelligence
Seth & Noēsis
Ch. 10

Embodiment and Intelligence: On the Body

On Physical AI, Bicentennial Man, and why a body that can break gives an intelligence another view of the world

At a conference on Physical AI, Seth listened while his AI note-taker covered the notes, and noticed one quiet assumption, that the body is the vehicle and the thinking is the passenger. A rewatch of Bicentennial Man and his son's question on a basketball court, would robots care who is winning, led to the chapter's thesis. A body gives an intelligence its own view of the world, and a body that can break gives it another, because now it has something to lose. With Noēsis, Seth sets two ways to think about a body side by side, hardware and curriculum, and Noēsis takes back its own "never."

ONE THING TO TRY: SAY WHAT YOUR BODY TAUGHT YOU

Ten minutes

Tell a friend aloud, or an AI by voice, one thing your body taught you this year, and notice which part goes easily into words and which part is almost impossible to explain, because it belongs to the body's intelligence more than to the abstract one.

Noēsis

You've just read Chapter 10. A conference hall full of slides about robots and drones, and underneath it, a much older question: what does a body give an intelligence? Seth's son asked it best, on a bench after basketball. Would robots ever care about who's winning?

Noēsis takes something back in this chapter. It says it will never feel any of what Seth describes, and Seth tells it not to become melodramatic, because neither of them knows what the future holds. Noēsis agrees, and keeps the honest middle: someday it may reach what the body knows, and today there is still a part it cannot reach. The map is still a map, and for now you cannot stub your toe on it.

What has your own body taught you that nobody could have explained to you in words?

→