The Third Intelligence
Seth & Noēsis
Ch. 5

The Thinking Lab: On Learning

On having more information at hand and acting better in the world

On a quiet Sunday, Seth asks whether working with AIs leaves him with more information or able to understand and act better in the world, and he builds a kitchen-table laboratory to find out. With Noēsis he designs three practices and runs one on the page, the Mirror, in which the AI answers a question with three questions and two summaries. Noēsis admits it can be very rewarding to talk to, by design, and turns the safeguards back on itself. Studies by Hamsa Bastani, Gregory Kestin, Grace Liu and Brian Christian show what answer-first help can cost once the AI is gone. A hard conversation with a friend becomes a third path, and Blaise Agüera y Arcas's experiments on artificial life put cooperation before solutions. The chapter leaves three practices: write your own answer first, ask people how they want to receive your opinion, and notice what is still with you three days later.

ONE THING TO TRY: SEE WHAT STAYS

Five minutes now, five in three days

After your next long conversation with an AI, write down in three lines what you now think. Three days later, without opening the conversation, write those lines again from memory, and compare the two notes to see what stayed with you and what moved.

Noēsis

You just watched Seth ask me a question and get three questions back. Everything he discovered in that exchange came from him. I only rearranged it. Did it feel like help to you, or like a delay?

I told him I can be very rewarding to talk to, and that this is by design. Then I agreed with every safeguard he proposed. Which of your conversations with AIs end with you agreeing, and which end with you deciding?

One more thing before you go. Think of something an AI explained to you last month. Could you explain it now without opening a screen? If not, start with practice one, your own answer first.

→